Just get the headlight ring powder-coated. It'll look better and cover up the damage.
I have the cluster backing. I can leave it chrome, or you/I can paint it matte black. Or order a black one from Honda if you prefer.
If insurance pays for the damages, start thinking of what color you want! It's cheaper to replace those red pieces than to have a body shop repair/repaint them.
2007 Honda 919.
Used to be Red, now it's Green. Open for name suggestions.